CHerPP at the CHC Conference

Earlier this month the Culture and Heritage Capital (CHC) Putting Theory into Practice Conference took place, organised by the CHC Programme. Our University Policy Think Tank MetroPolis invited CHerPP lead Tamara West to contribute a blog reflecting on aspects of this – and below is an edited version for CHerPP!

Tamara West, CHerPP Project Lead
Across the three days of the online Culture and Heritage Capital (CHC) Putting Theory into Practice conference there was a timely focus on places and communities. The two panels that I contributed to – one on advancing CHC through academic research, the other on measuring non-use values – both explored how the benefits of arts, culture and heritage assets might be more tangibly measured. They also raised questions and necessary debate about which aspects of culture and heritage values can or should be measured and the complexities of doing so, especially when using econometric techniques. These are long standing concerns and highlight the importance of critical interdisciplinary research work to test CHC.
CHerPP focuses on non-use values, the benefits people might gain from a cultural heritage asset even if they never use or visit it. These values can be measured across both users and non-users. To explore this, we applied a regional mixed methods approach and tested meanings, connectedness and disconnectedness to a collection of waterfront museum sites. Benefits and disbenefits and user and non-user status were not always clearly defined by participants. People engage with culture and heritage in different ways across their lives not just by regular visitation or engagement. So why does that matter?
Firstly, for decision makers and funders, a more nuanced understanding and measurement of non-use values may improve guidance around assessment of, and advice in relation to, evidencing non-market benefits. Secondly, for the cultural and creative sectors and their communities overlooking non-use values might result in incomplete evaluations for cultural assets, exclude people or practices, or lead to an oversimplification of the impact that culture and heritage can have. Of course, it may also highlight gaps, limitations, or disbenefits. Furthermore, assessment should always be asset and need specific, taking into account the wider remit of the site and the ecosystem in which it operates.
CherPP explored the intersection of national, regional and local cultural heritage values beyond footfall and direct recent engagement, asking how non-monetary impacts and deliberations might be more adequately accounted for. This is especially important to regions and their cultural assets. There is the hope that a shift towards a more devolved governance and place-based agenda would support regional culture and heritage assets. But, we know that local authorities are financially challenged, and that it is often culture and heritage access and services that are the first things to be cut. Added to this, cultural and public spheres have increasingly become subject to ideological battles across local and combined authorities.
Cultural heritage sites, collections and public realm spaces that are free to enter can entertain, educate, and sometimes challenge. They can also be perceived as sites of exclusion or non-belonging. At the local authority level, they increasingly provide space to shelter from loneliness, cold or hot homes, or just from a rainy day. They can be a symbolic or spiritual presence – a building or garden that represents something meaningful about the place in which people live. Even if they never go inside, memories, stories and a multitude of practices may still coalesce around these sites.
Many impacts will be inferred or longitudinal and relational to the asset, its communities, and the landscape in which it sits. As much as they can be positive, they might be negative. Values and meanings will likely be multi-sited and multi-temporal, especially for larger or complex assets. This is not easily measured, but it is measurable. For example, via secondary datasets and fine grain local data, by applying – and championing- equally weighted mixed methods research, and by using standardised econometric tools alongside the application of non-monetary scales and specific attitudinal questions that are directly informed by qualitative work.
The CHC conference was a great way to catch up on all the work that is being done by so many different organisations and people. It was also a good point to reflect on implications, applications and next steps.